Originally
posted by
mrford:
Originally
posted by
Rockman:
Originally
posted by
mrford:
rockman doesnt know the military code apparently. ordrs have to be lawful and moral. there would be large amount of dissension if the government ordered the military against its own civilians, since that is against the constitution.
not to mention that if the last 60 years have taught us anything it is that asymmetrical warfare on the part of a populace fighting for its home ans way of life can hold its own against a well armed and supported military force.
Orders have to be lawful and moral? I guess torturing people that aren't even being charged with a crime, or using chemical weapons is moral? The US military is anything but moral.
And the last 60 years (and more) have taught us that civil war always sucks. Turning a civilian area into a warzone is never ever good for the civilians living in that area. It is not a desirable outcome. No one thrives when fighting for their home and their way of life. Living through a war is horrible. It is not a solution.
you are so idealistic and generalization prone it is a wonder you have made it this far. seems like you form your opinions based on others and not your own real world experiences. shame. the torture was organised and carried out by a civilian organisation, not the military. and i dont think it was wide spread or in the same context as say ordering forces against their own countrymen. what a terrible analogy. are you feeling okay?
this is ignoring the fact that you keep changing your point from civilians couldnt oppose the government to it wouldnt be worth it. if you dont want to fight for your rights that is fine. dont mind me when i do. no one eer said it was ideal, but sometimes it is necessary.
with that said, it is not like we are anywhere close to a civil war right now, so i dont even know why this is being discussed. it is you and your worst case scenario mischaracterizations that have brought the topic here.
I form my opinions based not just on my real world experiences, but also on my extensive reading and my numerous friends from other countries. When you've got a lot of friends from Colombia and Brazil, and you're willing to learn about their experiences, you get a different perspective. Especially when you talk to people from Colombia or Mexico, you get to learn about what happens when violence is commonplace. When you actually learn history, you get to learn how the world works. When you learn the truth about the history of the US military, it is laughable when someone claims that the military only follows moral orders.
When you're finally ready to leave your American Exceptionalism bubble and to learn the truth about the world, and to get to know how people from outside the USA think, you'll find it is so very different.
FYI Guantanamo bay is a US MILITARY prison.
I've never said that standing up to the government as a lone individual would work, you're putting words in my mouth.
I don't want you fighting for your rights because it puts me in danger when you fight for your rights. I don't want my neighbor trying to use weaponry to defend himself from the government. I have the right to not have you jeopardizing my safety just because you're a paranoid delusional homicidal nutcase.
We are not close to a civil war, but when people are fighting against their own government, that would be a civil war. It's being discussed because people have this silly idea that the second amendment is what makes us free. If you can't see how I equate advocating using your guns against your own government with the idea of a civil war, then you're pretty clueless.