Verified:

Dark TwizTid

Patron
1387

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:08:00

So this one question has been pissing me off, and I have tried passing it and going back but it is really annoying.

Sqrt(x+4)=x^2-5

Now after working it out, I square each side to get:

X+4=x^4-10x^2+25

Then move the LHS to the RHS

0=x^4-10x^2-x+21

But that is where I get stuck. I can't seem to find a way to solve that...
Help please? Lol

mrford Game profile

Member
21,352

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:12:02

X=42

it always equals 42
Swagger of a Chupacabra

[21:37:01] <&KILLERfluffY> when I was doing FA stuff for sof the person who gave me the longest angry rant was Mr Ford

Rockman Game profile

Member
3388

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:12:17

Through derivation you can find out how many solutions there are and a general area in which to look for them.

Tertius Game profile

Member
EE Patron
1480

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:23:32

Not sure if you have some set way you need to solve it, but if you have a graphing calculator/program, then starting at the first equality and plotting both sides to find the intersect is probably the easiest way.

Edited By: Tertius on Feb 22nd 2011, 22:26:48. Reason: spelling
See Original Post

Pang Game profile

Administrator
Game Development
5731

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:23:47

0=x^4-10x^2-x+21
0 = (x^4 -10x^2 + 21) - x
0 = (x^2 - 3)(x^2 - 7) - x

that's as far as I'm able to get without looking up stuff from old math classes :p
-=Pang=-
Earth Empires Staff
pangaea [at] earthempires [dot] com

Boxcar - Earth Empires Clan & Alliance Hosting
http://www.boxcarhosting.com

Shinigami Game profile

Member
685

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:24:50

6x9

Duh

spawn Game profile

Member
1707

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:40:32

try to substitute x^2 with u or something
/slap iZarcon

All your deleted countries are belong to me!

BobbyATA Game profile

Member
2367

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:53:02

Ferrari's method should work fine, you already even have a depressed quartic so the first step is done for you. Duh...

or ya just plug it into a calculator:P

Dark TwizTid

Patron
1387

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:53:34

Ya I have tried substituting... have gotten nowhere heh thanks though :P

BobbyATA Game profile

Member
2367

Feb 22nd 2011, 22:54:01

-2.495325943, -1.882801176, 1.621432679, 2.756694440

Tertius Game profile

Member
EE Patron
1480

Feb 22nd 2011, 23:04:39

Keep in mind that two of those will not be solutions of the original equation. But it's easy enough to know that x^2-5 should be positive and so |x| > sqrt(5)

Dark TwizTid

Patron
1387

Feb 22nd 2011, 23:23:22

Thing is, this is math 12, should I know Ferrari's Method in math 12 or do you learn it a lot later in schooling?

PS. I suck at math :)

BobbyATA Game profile

Member
2367

Feb 22nd 2011, 23:37:16

twiztid, I dont' think they expect you to know Ferrari's Method. I don't think anyone is ever taught it, in high school/undergrad or grad school. Sorry my "duh" was meant to be completely sarcastic... (and to be clear the only reason I knew about ferrari's method is 2 minutes on google and then wikipedia;))

I think the point of the question is to plug it into calculator and then determine which solutions are actually solutions? Not exactly sure tbh...either that or your prof messed up and one of the constants is wrong or w/ever making the solutions not "nice."

spawn Game profile

Member
1707

Feb 22nd 2011, 23:38:12

Ferrari's method = fast method (as in fast cars) = using a calculator?
/slap iZarcon

All your deleted countries are belong to me!

Dukey Game profile

Member
140

Feb 23rd 2011, 7:05:53

there is no solution...

http://www.myalgebra.com/algebra_solver.aspx
copy and paste your equation in(have to use lowercase S in Sqrt for it to take) and it tells no solution. very useful tool though, hasn't been wrong yet(as long as you punch things in correctly with proper parenthesis' for it)

toma Game profile

Member
313

Feb 23rd 2011, 7:28:52

Dukey: it's a 4th order polynomial there's always 4 solutions per fundamental law of algebra.


http://www.wolframalpha.com/...?i=x%2B4%3D+%28x^2-5%29^2
Originally posted by Slagpit:
Ruining peoples fun for no reason is okay, but ruining it for a reason I disagree with isn't okay. Never change, community.

BobbyATA Game profile

Member
2367

Feb 23rd 2011, 16:40:43

not true toma. Try x^4+100=0.

Kingme Game profile

Member
1824

Feb 23rd 2011, 17:52:29

Originally posted by BobbyATA:
not true toma. Try x^4+100=0.


you are a nerd.

Tertius Game profile

Member
EE Patron
1480

Feb 23rd 2011, 18:46:16

Bobby: why would that one not still have four solutions?

Isn't it just +-sqrt(i)sqrt(10) and +-sqrt(-i)sqrt(10)?

Ozzite Game profile

Member
2122

Feb 23rd 2011, 18:51:02

Originally posted by BobbyATA:
twiztid, I dont' think they expect you to know Ferrari's Method. I don't think anyone is ever taught it, in high school/undergrad or grad school.


2nd semester of abstract algebra in undergrad....my professor was kinda nuts tho
Ah, mercury. Sweetest of the transition metals.

Ozzite Game profile

Member
2122

Feb 23rd 2011, 18:51:23

oh, also don't forget your imaginary roots =]
Ah, mercury. Sweetest of the transition metals.

BobbyATA Game profile

Member
2367

Feb 23rd 2011, 18:58:37

lol that sucks Ozzite, the method doesn't look like much fun to learn:P. And ya you guys are right of course about 4 complex roots, but I thought from the context of problem we were looking for real solution. My apologies if I misunderstood you toma!

Rockman Game profile

Member
3388

Feb 23rd 2011, 18:59:40

Originally posted by toma:
Dukey: it's a 4th order polynomial there's always 4 solutions per fundamental law of algebra.


http://www.wolframalpha.com/...?i=x%2B4%3D+%28x^2-5%29^2


There's always 4 complex roots, unless roots are repeated.




---------------------

If f(x) = x^4-10x^2-x+21
Then f'(x) = x^3 - 20x - 1

Where f'(x) = 0, f(x) has either a minimum or maximum (or inflection point I think in special cases). Since f'(x) is cubic, there will be as many as 3 solutions. Plugging these solutions into f(x) will tell you how many times the graph of f(x) crosses the axis, i.e. how many solutions there are.

Unfortunately, f'(x) doesn't appear to factor easily, so finding the roots of f'(x) is also a rather difficult task.

f''(x) = 3x^2-20
If we let u=sqrt(20)/sqrt(3) (because I'm lazy) Then
f''(x) = 3(x+u)(x-u)
f''(x) crosses the axis twice, thus f'(x) has 0 slope twice. Since f'(x) has a positive leading coefficient, this means it has a maximum at -u and a minimum at u

f'(x) = x^3 - 20x - 1
if we approximate u=2.582 then
f'(-u)= -17.213 + 51.64 - 1 = positive
f'(u) = 17.213-51.64 -1 = negative


Thus, f'(x) crosses the axis 3 times
Since f'(x) crosses the axis 3 times and f(x) has a positive leading coefficient, f(x) has 2 minima and 1 maximum

Find these minima and the maximum and you'll know how many real roots f(x) has.

ibujke Game profile

Member
240

Feb 23rd 2011, 19:19:17

Originally posted by Tertius:
Keep in mind that two of those will not be solutions of the original equation. But it's easy enough to know that x^2-5 should be positive and so |x| > sqrt(5)


True, but also X>=-4 so its

(X>=sqrt(5) or X<=-sqrt(5))
and
X>=-4


as for the actual solution, im not sure if this works but:

Sqrt(x+4)=x^2-5
log(Sqrt(x+4))= log(x^2-5)
10^log(Sqrt(x+4))= 10^log(x^2-5)
10^(1/2*log(x+4))= 10^log(x^2-5)
10^1/2 * 10^log(x+4))= 10^log(x^2-5)
10^1/2 * (x+4)= x^2-5
x^2 - sqrt(10)*x - 4*sqrt(10) - 5 = 0
which is
x^2 - b*x - c = 0
where
b= sqrt(10)
c=4*sqrt(10)-5

etc

using the fact that 10^log(x)=x and that log(x^2)=2*log(x)

I dont have time to check it out though.

Ozzite Game profile

Member
2122

Feb 23rd 2011, 19:21:48

Originally posted by BobbyATA:
lol that sucks Ozzite, the method doesn't look like much fun to learn:P. And ya you guys are right of course about 4 complex roots, but I thought from the context of problem we were looking for real solution. My apologies if I misunderstood you toma!


we didn't really need to learn it per se, but there was an afternoon where the prof just went off on the board and went through the whole solution method and stuff.
Ah, mercury. Sweetest of the transition metals.

Chevs

Member
2061

Feb 23rd 2011, 20:48:18

I have a bellybutton
SOF Head Of Poop
2019-04-03 21:40:26 PS the stinky deyicks (#599) Beryl Houston (#360) LaF 30638A (43783A)
En4cer: Chevs... u would have beaten me by more than 100m

skitch Game profile

Member
96

Feb 26th 2011, 20:02:20

hahaha chevs thanks for contributing.