Originally
posted by
hoop:
This will be an interesting test in if we remain a free nation or if we give up freedoms like we did after 9/11. I'm not sure chanting USA makes much sense. This was definitely NOT a good day for America.
The trial and how we handle this will be very interesting as well. Not reading him his rights is just dumbfounding.
You aren't sure chanting USA makes much sense?
After an entire city was put on lockdown by two who set off explosions for the sole purpose of killing citizens of the USA?
See that's the problems with you guys at Harvard. You don't understand this city. You aren't from here and you won't stay here.
My family came here, to Boston, over 100 years ago. I've stood at that finish line, my fiancé has, my parents have, my grandparents have. I know people affected.
I live and work in the neighborhood hit.
My family lives and works here.
We have for generations.
You see, Boston is a tough neighborhood and sometimes our manners aren't fit for polite society - but anyone with any sense would know that the good people of Boston had all right to chant for their city and the USA for ONE HOUR before settling back into mourning. It's what Martin Richard's parents wanted.
We weren't chanting USA in jest. Or boastfully. But with honor. that chant meant one thing - we won't forget Martin and the others and we WILL get you. WE WILL GET YOU.
anyone that wants to bring harm to innocent children - WE WILL GET YOU.
Whatever that means. The collective WE. But We here in Boston and We here in the USA will get you.
And Boston IS the USA. WE INVENTED THE USA.
the very ideals and foundations of this city are at this country's core.
And most importantly we were chanting immediately after and ONLY immediately after the capture of someone who did harm to this city and people in it. Harm to this country and people in it.
So we chanted USA
Guys like you always try to spin things back to Academia, to your cutesy little cafes where you can discuss things in theory with your fellow cambridge quacks. This is real life. We aren't talking about this in theory. We are talking about real things and real life and real loss and real emotion.
real emotion isn't supposed to make "sense".
I find it so deeply offensive you said that during this time. There were so many people in that crowd suffering much more loss than I and they'd be devastated to hear such classroom nonsense.
If you took the time to read my post you would have clearly seen that the chanting of USA was an emotional response after the capture of someone who was on the loose and aiming to harm more.
And his ideology included deep anti-U.S. sentiment.
The impromptu celebrations on Friday night have nothing to do with personal freedoms or 9/11 - nor was it a matter of things making "sense". It was pure emotion.
Not a classroom at Harvard, hoop.
If you continued to read you would have seen:
'But after all the celebrating I think many of us in Boston are starting to sober up again and are finally able to look back to the victims of this horrific act. "
No one said this was a good day for America. It was a horrible day. No one was chanting USA and saying "hey what an amazing day for America". No.
And of course the mood immediately sobered the next day and many who had been in the raucous crowd were truly with heavy heart and attended the memorial at Berkeley street - where I assure you, no chanting was heard.
The mood in Back Bay remains very somber. Thoughts are again with the victims.
...
Not reading his rights is dumbfounding?
See - I can appreciate and understand your stance.
But dumfounding? You certainly don't care to listen to opinions other than your own.
Dumbfounding? Even though reading him his rights may prevent us from extracting more information that could potentially save more U.S. lives?
So sure, call it unconstitutional, call it something you're against.
But don't call it dumbfounding you elitist punk.
Rest assured there are plenty at both MIT and by you that are just as intelligent and most certainly do not share your opinion. So dumbfounding?
So to be frank,
Take your Harvard elitism elsewhere and while you're at it, book a flight back to California.